Skip to content
  • BTC $58,468 −6.1%
  • ETH $1,602 −9.3%
  • SOL $67.55 −7.7%
  • BNB $534.74 −8.2%
  • XRP $0.8886 −8.0%
  • DOGE $0.0530 −9.2%
  • ADA $0.1396 −8.3%

Arthur Hayes crypto turns defensive, shuns Bitcoin for gold and HYPE in 2025 war risk

This arthur hayes crypto outlook shifts defensive as macro and geopolitical risks rise, highlighting gold and HYPE hedges amid rising risk.

arthur hayes crypto
Arthur Hayes Crypto outlook turns defensive with gold, HYPE

In a new macro commentary, Arthur Hayes crypto views have shifted toward caution as he steps back from active trading and focuses on defensive positioning.

Arthur Hayes steps aside from trading in a “no-trade zone” market

Arthur Hayes, co-founder of BitMEX and CIO of Maelstrom, says he has barely traded during the first quarter of 2025, describing the current digital asset landscape as a “no-trade zone” in an April 15 post. He argues that traders are underestimating how rapidly macro risks are evolving.

He attributes his caution to two major forces: the rapid advance of AI agents that can replace knowledge workers, and the escalating US-Iran confrontation over the strategic Strait of Hormuz. Together, these dynamics could destabilize both labor markets and global energy flows, with direct consequences for risk assets.

Hayes writes that he prefers patience over chasing short-term rallies. However, he concedes that volatility could surge quickly if either technology disruptions or geopolitical flashpoints accelerate faster than consensus expects.

AI disruption, unemployment and credit risk

According to Hayes, the rise of automation could trigger a sharp increase in consumer credit defaults, as laid-off workers struggle to service debts. He explicitly compares this potential shock to the 2008 subprime mortgage crisis, warning that the financial system is more fragile than markets admit.

He cites a crypto gaming company CEO who used artificial intelligence to complete a six-month roadmap in just four days, then cut 50% of the team. Moreover, he suggests that similar restructuring could become common across software, finance and media as firms lean on AI to reduce payrolls.

Hayes notes that the US median unemployment payout sits around $28,000 per year, while median knowledge workers earn roughly $85,000 to $90,000. That said, he argues this income gap will leave many displaced workers unable to keep up with loans, potentially stressing banks and consumer lenders.

Three Bitcoin paths tied to conflict at the Strait of Hormuz

Hayes outlines three distinct Bitcoin price scenarios, each linked to how the conflict around the Strait of Hormuz resolves. The first scenario assumes the war ends and trade flows normalize, allowing AI-driven “deflation” to continue as automation cuts costs but weakens labor income and credit quality.

In that outcome, Hayes expects the Federal Reserve would eventually need to print money to prevent a banking collapse triggered by rising defaults. However, he does not believe that point has arrived, which is why he is reluctant to accumulate more coins yet.

The second scenario envisions Iran maintaining control of the shipping chokepoint and charging tolls in yuan, crypto, or gold. In that case, he says nations might sell US dollar assets to pay these fees, putting pressure on treasuries, stocks, and Bitcoin as portfolios are rebalanced.

The third path sees the US destroying Iran’s ability to control the strait. Hayes warns that Tehran would likely retaliate by targeting Gulf energy infrastructure, forcing global central banks to print money to stabilize markets and inflation expectations. In all three scenarios, he concludes that significant monetary expansion eventually arrives.

Why Hayes is not buying Bitcoin yet

Despite expecting future money printing, Hayes insists he will not aggressively buy Bitcoin until the Fed clearly signals a return to balance sheet expansion. He suggests that waiting for this policy pivot offers a more favorable risk-reward profile than front-running it based on speculation alone.

He acknowledges that the coin could still spike to $80,000–$90,000 even before such a signal emerges. Moreover, he concedes that traders willing to accept higher downside risk might choose to ride that potential upside. That said, he frames his own stance as conservative capital preservation rather than momentum chasing.

For now, he characterizes the market as a tactical environment, not a strategic one. In his view, leverage and aggressive positioning are best avoided until policy clarity and macro trends align more clearly in favor of digital assets.

Current positioning: gold and Hyperliquid’s HYPE

Hayes reveals that Maelstrom is focusing on alternative hedges instead of expanding its crypto holdings. Specifically, he says Maelstrom is only adding gold and Hyperliquid’s HYPE token at this stage, aligning its portfolio with what he sees as asymmetrical opportunities.

He highlights the MOVE Index, which tracks US bond market volatility, as a key macro indicator. If it rises above 130, he expects some form of money printing to follow. However, until that threshold is breached, he prefers to keep risk limited and focus on selective trades.

At the time of his commentary, gold is trading near $4,830, up about 1% on the day. Meanwhile, HYPE is up roughly 18% over the past week, around $45.31, reflecting growing interest in the Hyperliquid ecosystem among on-chain traders.

Hyperliquid, HIP-4 and sector competition

Beyond macro hedges, Hayes singles out Hyperliquid as a potential structural winner in the on-chain derivatives and prediction markets niche. He argues that the project’s upcoming HIP-4 launch could trigger a significant rally in HYPE if liquidity and user growth accelerate as expected.

Moreover, he believes Hyperliquid may take market share from established competitors such as Polymarket and Kalshi, especially if users prioritize speed and capital efficiency. While this view adds a growth angle to Maelstrom’s positioning, he stresses that it remains a targeted bet rather than a broad-based risk-on stance.

In this framework, the arthur hayes crypto portfolio tilts toward scarce assets and high-conviction protocol plays while avoiding overexposure to cyclical beta. It combines macro hedging with selective speculation, reflecting his belief that both AI disruption and geopolitical risk are still underpriced.

Overall, Hayes portrays 2025 as a transition year in which AI-driven job losses, geopolitical tensions and policy uncertainty could collide. Until money printing visibly resumes and market structure stabilizes, he plans to stay cautious, favoring gold, HYPE and optionality over full exposure to Bitcoin and broader crypto.

Amelia Tomasicchio

As expert in digital marketing, Amelia began working in the fintech sector in 2014 after writing her thesis on Bitcoin technology. Previously author for several international crypto-related magazines and CMO at Eidoo. She is now the co-founder of The Cryptonomist. She is also a marketing teacher at Digital Coach in Milan and she published a book about NFTs for the Italian publishing house Mondadori, while she is also helping artists and company to entering in the sector. As advisor, Amelia is also involved in metaverse-related project such as The Nemesis and OVER.

All articles by Amelia Tomasicchio